Print Page | Close Window

consistancy troubles

Printed From: Nasgaweb
Category: Nasgaweb Forums
Forum Name: Training
Forum Discription: This forum is for discussion about training for the Scottish Heavy Events.
URL: http://www.nasgaweb.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=14689
Printed Date: 3/26/26 at 9:51pm
Software Version: Web Wiz Forums 10.11 - http://www.webwizforums.com


Topic: consistancy troubles
Posted By: JSiau10
Subject: consistancy troubles
Date Posted: 9/26/11 at 10:28am
does anyone have any good tricks for keeping in the habit of going to the gym? I love going, and I mean to go twice a week, but I have trouble keeping to it.

-------------
I'm just an idiot, pretending to be smart.



Replies:
Posted By: Hapy
Date Posted: 9/26/11 at 12:22pm
Having a training partner is the only way I have found to keep anything close
to real consistency.

-------------
Real Men Wear Purple

Tinky Winky Throw Far!

http://www.facebook.com/CVTSA" rel="nofollow - Central Vermont Strength Association


Posted By: C. Smith
Date Posted: 9/26/11 at 12:30pm
Originally posted by JSiau10 JSiau10 wrote:

does anyone have any good tricks for keeping in the habit of going to the gym? I love going, and I mean to go twice a week, but I have trouble keeping to it.


Does not compute.


I don't like being a skinny weakling.  That does it for me.  I don't need anyone else.


-------------


Posted By: Sammy68123
Date Posted: 9/26/11 at 3:36pm

Originally posted by JSiau10 JSiau10 wrote:

does anyone have any good tricks for keeping in the habit of going to the gym? I love going, and I mean to go twice a week, but I have trouble keeping to it.

Why do you have trouble keeping to doing something you love? 

1)  Scheduling it like an appointment for anything else--you don't break it.

2)  Having a plan of what to do, even if somewhat general.  Each workout doesn't have to be a balls-to-the-wall session.  Consistency is more important.

3)  I kind of hate being really sore, which is what any interruption of a week or more inevitably creates.  Consistency is what keeps that from happening. 

4)  Another way to keep up my energy expenditure so I can still enjoy eating somewhat while maintaining my weight.  You gentlemen probably don't worry as much about these things unless you're under 190-200 class.  But even WITH exercise, I get about 2000-2200 cals per day to maintain (not easy to do).  So I make sure I get my workout in so I get to EAT to match.

Being a person who falls into a somewhat middle "gray" zone of people who don't easily find training partners, I find I have to rely on myself for overcoming the internal/external barriers that would keep me from lifting.  I decided that I had to keep going for myself despite the availability of any possible training partners.



-------------
Teresa Merrick
Bellevue, NE


Posted By: celtuckian
Date Posted: 9/27/11 at 8:05am

Originally posted by JSiau10 JSiau10 wrote:

does anyone have any good tricks for keeping in the habit of going to the gym? I love going, and I mean to go twice a week, but I have trouble keeping to it.

Getting to the gym on a consistent basis requires having a reason/purpose for going.  If the only reason for going is to sling around a few weights because inner guilt says you should be going, then you are probably better srved by not going at all.  Having a prpose and a plan for not only what you are going to do but also why is the first step.

Secondly, going to the gym has to be an integral part of your day, like eating or going to work or taking your kid to school.  It is something that is just done as a matter of course.  It should be something that you just do.  Twice a week is more of a distraction than a regular part of the day.

I'm certainly not an authority by any means, but this is what works for me.  That, and as Craig noted, not wanting to be a skinny weakling (although I haven't yet accomplished NOT being a skinny weakling).    Fear can be a fantastic motivator.



-------------
Brian Ely
"Well, throwing harder didn't work" - T. Brazewell


Posted By: Sammy68123
Date Posted: 9/27/11 at 1:41pm
Originally posted by celtuckian celtuckian wrote:

Secondly, going to the gym has to be an integral part of your day, like eating or going to work or taking your kid to school.  It is something that is just done as a matter of course.  It should be something that you just do.  Twice a week is more of a distraction than a regular part of the day.

+1!  Consistency: exercise is something you do every day, like brush teeth, eat, feed dog--whatever similar activities that you do.  Does not have to be the same kind of exercise each day; but exercise itself happens each day unless you're dead, unconscious, have an acute illness with symptoms below the neck, or are physically restrained (strapped to) in bed by a physician.  If none of those apply, then make it happen.

Some people can consistently work out 3 times a week and stay with it.  For many others, however, working out feels like some kind of "penance" (for the Christians/Catholics among the readers) and off days become some kind of reprieve from it.  Those people need to just make exercise a matter-of-fact part of the day.

The title of one research study I cited in my dissertation really summed it up: "Just Do It, Before You Talk Yourself Out of It".



-------------
Teresa Merrick
Bellevue, NE


Posted By: JSiau10
Date Posted: 9/27/11 at 5:46pm
 the largest reason I have troubles with consistancy problems is because I am easily distracted. I can wake up in the morning and say "I'm going to the gym today" and somewhere along the way I get off track.

-------------
I'm just an idiot, pretending to be smart.


Posted By: C. Smith
Date Posted: 9/27/11 at 10:57pm
Does the same thing happen with going to work?  I suspect it doesn't and therefore your excuse doesn't hold water. 

Read Brian and Teresa's posts again, and make it a part of your schedule like they stated, cause it's clear you don't love it as much as you think you do. 


-------------


Posted By: jsully
Date Posted: 9/28/11 at 1:55am

I used to train 5 days a week in the gym. A HG pro told me to train like a thrower. That = throw a lot. So I dropped down to only 2 days/wk in the gym.

I want to pull my beard out if I have to push back one of those days. I despise missing workouts.



Posted By: ROB EVANS
Date Posted: 9/28/11 at 2:43am
one word.  DISCIPLINE. 

-------------
If Spencer Tyler is the gamma bomb of explosion, you and I are like single-serving flan cups in his lunchbox. Pasty, Jiggly, Delicious, but otherwise not very explosive. DUNCAN MCCALLUM


Posted By: jsully
Date Posted: 9/28/11 at 2:55am
I have the words "power. strength. discipline" tattoed on the inside of my upper arm. A constant reminder of what I need to have to reach my goals. Cheesy? Maybe, but eff you I like it.


Posted By: 17/20
Date Posted: 9/28/11 at 7:08am

Youre really not committed I would say.



-------------
I MAY BE BIG , BUT I'M FAST


Posted By: ROB EVANS
Date Posted: 9/28/11 at 7:36am

On a lighter note your work out maybe overly complex and you dread (or may not have recovered) your next work out so mentally you're not prepared or get exhausted just thinking about slinging weights for a couple of hours. 

I have switched to 4 days a week focusing on Squats, Deadlifts, Benchpress and Standing OH Press in the gym. 

The other two Wednesday (see below) I do other stuff whether it's throwing in the Back yard or something.  Sunday = Honey Due list.

If I do those I count it as a "W" for the week.  All the other stuff is fluff.  IMHO. I maybe in and out in 30 - 45 minutes.

I don't go on Wednesdays and Friday nights because that's when having teenagers dictate that I drive them everywhere and by the time I log a long week of work I just want to go home and veg-out on the couch. <- Sometimes you just need to do this.

So this is what my week looks like

MON  BP and other crap if time permits

Tuesday Squats and Single leg deadlifts and other crap if time permits

Wednesday Back yard, Kettlebell, running, Taking the kids too and from church.

Thursday OH Press and other stuff

Friday Not a dang thing

Saturday Deadlifts

Sunday Some assistance work, KB, Backyard stuff.

Not the most perfect training plan.  But it's evolving. 



-------------
If Spencer Tyler is the gamma bomb of explosion, you and I are like single-serving flan cups in his lunchbox. Pasty, Jiggly, Delicious, but otherwise not very explosive. DUNCAN MCCALLUM


Posted By: Sean
Date Posted: 10/05/11 at 1:25am

If you aren't naturally motivated and need something to keep it up, I would say a partner is the worst thing in the world. Then you tie your motivation in on an external factor. No bueno.

What you need is a PLAN.

"I'm going to get up and go to the gym tomorrow!" is not a plan.

"Shit, if I don't get up tomorrow, I miss my week 3, day 2 squat session." is a plan.

I know some guys train "by feel" but I think the majority around here have a pretty freakin good idea what they would be training 4 weeks from now on a Thursday if they were asked.

Come up with an 8 week plan. Reps, sets, weights, cardio, stretching, you name it. Stick with that plan.

Once you get the habit formed and get some instincts, you can train a little looser. For now, keep your freedom limited. It's Boot Camp. Remove the thinking process from it all together. The Piece of Paper is your master now.



Posted By: Silverback
Date Posted: 10/05/11 at 4:48am
You make a decision now.  When it is time to go to the gym you just go, you already made a decision.  Don't make the decision every day when it is time to work out.  Besides, what is more fun in your day then training?  What ever it is, you can do it after you train.  I train because I am selfish, I love it, need it and it keeps me more sane.  Nobody around me wants me to miss training.  I don't even like to think about skinny, I have issues man.  

-------------
Mule

Sportkilt
AST Sport Supplements


Posted By: Skullsplitter
Date Posted: 10/05/11 at 7:50am
Wow, I have to agree with Craig, Mule and 17/20. I just don't get not having
the motivation to train. I worked all night the last 2 nights. I took a nap this
morning, got up and trained like my life depended on it. Ask yourself some
real questions about why you do this sport. Yes, throw for sure but the
weight training is needed for improving performance on the throws for most
of us. So, if you want to throw well you should be hard wired to lift.

Bill

-------------
"I am the thread, the pupil, and the eye of the needle is my teacher"


Posted By: D. Haakenson
Date Posted: 10/05/11 at 8:43am
Originally posted by Skullsplitter Skullsplitter wrote:

Yes, throw for sure but the
weight training is needed for improving performance on the throws for most
of us. So, if you want to throw well you should be hard wired to lift.

Bill


I don't think this is true exactly. I know many talented throwers who are not "hard wired" to lift. The term "hard wired" kind of implies that there is nothing you can do to change it. So I like to think that you can do things you are not hard wired to do.

I myself am not a person who naturally loves weight lifting but over the past 10 years I've grown to sometimes enjoy it, or at least respect the process and I've become curious about and interested in training theory. However, there are many levels of our sport, and without being too contrary to previous posters, I suggest that at your level, Josh, throwing is vastly more important than lifting. You have to have volume and you have to have a consistent and systematic approach to throws training and record keeping.

That's my two cents.

Daniel


Posted By: C. Smith
Date Posted: 10/06/11 at 12:39am
Quote hard-wire (härdwr)tr.v.
hard-wired

<snip>
3. To determine or put into effect by physiological or neurological mechanisms; make automatic or innate


Originally posted by D. Haakenson D. Haakenson wrote:

  I suggest that at your level, Josh, throwing is vastly more important than lifting.


Most of the time I would agree with this statement, but Josh's base strength is so low, that at a minimum throwing and lifting should be 50/50 imo. 


-------------


Posted By: D. Haakenson
Date Posted: 10/06/11 at 2:35pm

hard-wired

3.
pertaining to or being an intrinsic and relatively unmodifiable behavior pattern: Every cricket has a hard-wired pattern of chirps.

We use different dictionaries.

Josh, I hope that you don't mind the hijacking of your thread for this purpose but I think this is an interesting case.

Having read Josh's training log and seen him throw, I think its fair to say that his log does not indicate what his strength levels are. In fact I think the only thing his log indicates is that he is not aware of his strength.

At this level almost anything you do is going to make you improve; in fact I imagine that if you do nothing you will probably continue to improve slightly. In this case, I think you should train in the way that makes you feel the best. If you have to drag yourself to the gym and you hate it, why do it? Throw until you come to the realization that you have improved as much as you can without lifting. Then the desire to become stronger will have become an intrinsic desire rather than one thrust upon you.  The power of desire is way more important than going from a 50kg back squat to a 100kg back squat.


Posted By: C. Smith
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 12:43am
Originally posted by D. Haakenson D. Haakenson wrote:


Having read Josh's training log and seen him throw, I think its fair to say that his log does not indicate what his strength levels are. In fact I think the only thing his log indicates is that he is not aware of his strength.


Perhaps.  I have not seen him throw so I can only base my advice on what he said and what he lists in his training log, which seems void of any discernible programming, despite receiving advice.   

Originally posted by D. Haakenson D. Haakenson wrote:

At this level almost anything you do is going to make you improve;


Agree. 

Originally posted by D. Haakenson D. Haakenson wrote:

Throw until you come to the realization that you have improved as much as you can without lifting. Then the desire to become stronger will have become an intrinsic desire rather than one thrust upon you.  The power of desire is way more important than going from a 50kg back squat to a 100kg back squat.


More that one way to skin a cat I suppose...just not the way I'd recommended learning to throw heavy stuff far, is all I'm saying. 


-------------


Posted By: Silverback
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 1:16am
Nobody that is weak is going to throw our stuff far.  Period and end of story.  Action talks and bullshit walks.  

-------------
Mule

Sportkilt
AST Sport Supplements


Posted By: Mr. Natural
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 3:43am

I have to go with Haakenson on this one. Throwing WILL make you stronger, and if you're just starting out then technique is way more important than strength anyway.

As far as motivation goes, you have to really enjoy training to stick with it.  You and Craigor are guys who love lifting weights and being strong - you're weightlifters who throw.  A lot of guys, including me, would never see the inside of a gym if we weren't doing the games. I'm a thrower who lifts, and I really want to clear 17' next year after I turn 40. So it's back to a winter of front squats and power cleans for me.

Do what you love, and it'll never feel like work.



Posted By: C. Smith
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 4:22am
Originally posted by Mr. Natural Mr. Natural wrote:

A lot of guys, including me, would never see the inside of a gym if we weren't doing the games. I'm a thrower who lifts, and I really want to clear 17' next year after I turn 40. So it's back to a winter of front squats and power cleans for me.


So, you're going to the gym so you can throw farther?  Isn't that what I essentially said?


-------------


Posted By: jsully
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 4:40am

this thread title gives the presumption it will be about poo, meh, if you replace the a with an e.

disappointing.



Posted By: rknebel
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 6:55am

In no way is this meant to put down Josh, but in this particular case he really needs to get in the weight room.  Working on technique and developing strength from throwing is very important but you have to at least have a bare minimum strength level to begin with in order to even get the weights moving.  From watching Josh throw a few times, he does not have that minimum strength level to receive much benefit from just practicing throwing.  My opinion would be that if he continues to throw and not develop a base strength level he will develop bad habits and his technique will struggle when he does finally develop that base strengh level. 

Josh - I don't believe you have any games coming up for quite some time.  Get in the weight room and develop some strength, put on some weight, and maybe throw once every 1-2 weeks, if that.  Again, this is not meant to be a put down to you but you have a lot of work to do as far as strength goes and spending more time throwing than lifting will not do you nearly as much good as lifting 4-5 times a week.  The other thing that would help you would be to put on some weight.  Your offseason should look like this:  EAT-LIFT-EAT-LIFT-EAT-EAT-EAT-LIFT-EAT!!!!



Posted By: Alan H
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 7:02am
Josh, I didn't lift at all during/between my first and second seasons.  That was because I was doing HG as a distraction of sorts...something to do to take my mind off of the fact that I was totally burned out on what I really loved to do, which was to sail, solo.  So I threw 1-2x a week and I got  somewhat stronger and better.

So, because I didn't lift weights, I'm a substandard specimen cum excuse for a human being?

After I did the 2008 Transpac  and sold the boat I was left with  a vacuum in my life.... what to do?  I had started HG, so I stuck with it. That next season I discovered that I wanted to do significantly better. So I lifted semi-regularly in the gym. I discovered that this gym time wasn't so bad, I  kind of enjoyed it.  The next year I wanted to do even better so I spent the entire off-season, like clockwork, in the gym 3 x a week.  For this 2011 season I had definite goals, I KNEW I had to get stronger, so this past winter I lifted religiously 3x a week AND threw all winter.  While this past season was not a breakthrough season, like 2010 was, I still improved in several events.

Now I have to decide what I want to do for next year, 2012. I have to set priorites and goals.  I'm pretty sure I want to go to the MWC, and I'm not gonna go there halfassed, so I expect I will be working hard this offseason.  I might get to go to Scotland and throw at 3-4 Games there, and I know I'll be throwing the 56, so I'd better build some strength this offseason, eh?

But 2013?  I don't know.  Maybe I'll ramp it back quite a bit. Who knows?

What makes me hit the gym?  A.) the desire to throw better... B.) the certain knowledge that as I age, I'm going to lose strength and speed and I want to be hiking the mountains and riding my bike and XC skiing when I'm 75 years old. If I want to do that, I had better stay active.

Those are my reasons.

You have to find your own reasons.  If you don't find reasons that motivate you to get in there, then that's fine despite the chest-thumping going on in this thread about skinny weaklings.  "Not going to the gym" is not a terminal character flaw, 85% of the population of North America doesn't visit  the gym and lift weights.   it's fine, now because you're in your 20's.  I will tell you that it won't be so fine when you're in your 50's and 60's.  When the day comes that you have to help your dad in and out of his wheelchair, you will suddenly understand why it's a freaking good idea to do some squats and box jumps.

There are some big, strong guys saying hard things to you in here. That's because they have strong priorities, and their priorities, which are very important to them, are probably VERY different from your priorities....*I Think* ...

Nobody can help you set your priorities.  If other people seem to judge you on your decisions and your priorities, then that's THEIR problem.  This is YOUR life.

I will say this, though.
 
 Quit asking for advice and moseying around half-committed.  If you are happy doing this as a low-key recreational activity, then you don't have to justify it to anybody. Just DO it...at whatever level you want. It's YOUR life, you make YOUR decisions.  Go read Steve Job's quotes about following your own heart.

But knock off the training log and all the questions and so on, and whining about motivation and all that.  Just stop it. If you don't want to ramp up the lifting and HG, then I'm for sure not going to judge you on that decision.  Other might, but I sure won't.   But IMHO  you come  off looking like an ass if you keep asking questions and getting advice, and posting here etc. etc. etc. and then never DO ANYTHING ABOUT IT.

Do it, or do not. Your choice.  Your life.

Alan


-------------
Alan Hebert

Geezer-In-Training


Posted By: rknebel
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 7:02am
-


Posted By: rknebel
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 7:09am

Originally posted by C. Smith C. Smith wrote:


Most of the time I would agree with this statement, but Josh's base strength is so low, that at a minimum throwing and lifting should be 50/50 imo. 

Or I could have just read the entire thread more thoroughly and just said "this".



Posted By: Alan H
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 7:12am
Robin K and Dan H know you personally.  They know your body type, your strength levels, your throwing ability. I've never actually seen you throw, but of course we've met several times.  If you want to improve, then read what Robin and Dan have to say.  Then..

...go do it.

Truth:  If you want to see significant gains in your throwing next season, you are going to have to  both put on some weight, AND gain a significant amount of strength. You are not going to be able to get as strong as Robin in one offseason. You are not going to throw 70 foot LWFD next year.  But you CAN improve significantly.




-------------
Alan Hebert

Geezer-In-Training


Posted By: mthompson33
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 7:14am
As a relative NooB in this sport, I have recent first hand experience in being weak and un-conditioned...  There is a very important factor that I haven't seen mentioned. 

There is a certain amount of strength and mobility required to do the events and not seriously injure yourself. 

Throwing will make you stronger for throwing, but it will NOT build your body in a balanced and symmetric manner.  I can personally attest to what happens when you start improving your throws and DO NOT have a WELL BALANCED strength base with GOOD MOBILITY...  Let's just say my A.R.T. guy has made over $4k off my insurance this year...

There is also a minimal amount of strength and mobility required to throw FAR (I'm not there yet).  From what I see, technique can take you farther than strength (with the risk of injury increasing as you improve).  My offseason this year (start of my 3rd year throwing) will be improving mobility and strength/power with a healthy dose of technique. 

Were I starting over again I would still focus on:

Squat
Deads
Presses
Rows

However I would give MUCH MORE EMPHASIS on MOBILITY.  Build the strength gradually and correctly.  Do the proper accessory work and spend a good amount of time each day on MOBILITY...  I'm still a mess as far as mobility goes, but I'm way ahead of where I was last year.


-------------
Matt Thompson

"If you wake up and you're not in pain, you know you're dead." -- Russian Proverb


Posted By: thegnome
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 7:30am

Going to the gym/throwing/picking up weird stuff in our yards is sort of who we are.  Even little old me.  I mean seriously, what else would I do or who else would want me? The basic answer is the trick to going twice a week is to actually go twice a week.  Just get through the door or on the field, the rest takes care of itself.

 

 



-------------
Andrew G

Vada a bordo CAZZO!!!!


Posted By: thegnome
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 7:38am
Can I give an example?  This week has been terribly busy at work, and I've had practice or games every night + a sick kid + another one with a Dentist appointment.  I got in my workout Wed night.  Tommorrow I have a soccer game to coach right in the middle of the day, then I need to try to get my old truck started, cut the grass and pack up to take my oldest boy on his birthday trip for the rest of the weekend.  no time for the gym...so I'll lift the big rocks in my yard, throw a bunch of shit in a sled and pull it around my yard, then figure out something to press.  There's always a way.  What do you have at home? 

-------------
Andrew G

Vada a bordo CAZZO!!!!


Posted By: D. Haakenson
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 7:41am
Consider this as food for thought. There is a group of people that competed in highland games for generations without ever weight lifting in a gym. These throwers never touched a barbell or foam rolled. I refer, of course, to the highlanders who invented this sport and threw for hundreds of years before the concept of weight lifting came into being.



Posted By: rknebel
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 8:09am

Originally posted by D. Haakenson D. Haakenson wrote:

Consider this as food for thought. There is a group of people that competed in highland games for generations without ever weight lifting in a gym. These throwers never touched a barbell or foam rolled. I refer, of course, to the highlanders who invented this sport and threw for hundreds of years before the concept of weight lifting came into being.

How would they fare in a competition against the throwers of our times.  Not just in 1 or 2 events but in the overall.  My guess is that they would likely get their a$$ handed to them. 



Posted By: D. Haakenson
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 8:15am
Originally posted by rknebel rknebel wrote:


My guess is that they would likely get their a$$ handed to them. 


Almost certainly. But to say that you can't throw without hurting yourself if you don't lift weights is ridiculous.



Posted By: Alan H
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 8:26am
Originally posted by D. Haakenson D. Haakenson wrote:

Originally posted by rknebel rknebel wrote:


My guess is that they would likely get their a$$ handed to them. 


Almost certainly. But to say that you can't throw without hurting yourself if you don't lift weights is ridiculous.



Agreed.  And you can have fun, hang with the guys, impress the fiancee...all that stuff without ever going in the gym.

Not everybody throws for the same reasons.  My reasons are different from Robins, whose got different reasons from Dan, and we're all different from Josh.  It might be that Josh is perfectly happy throwing at the level he's throwing at now.

I kind of think not, though. Cause if he was, if he didn't care to throw farther, then why would he be on this board?  But that's just my assumption and we all know about assumptions.

One thing for certain though. If Josh wants to see significant improvement, ESPECIALLY in the heavier events with the 56 and the caber,  he's going to have to add some strength and mass.


-------------
Alan Hebert

Geezer-In-Training


Posted By: D. Haakenson
Date Posted: 10/07/11 at 8:32am
The only thing I can say for certain is that all things being equal, you can't be too strong. 


Posted By: Sean
Date Posted: 10/08/11 at 11:04am
Yeah, I don't think there's ever a scenario where anyone has ever said "I wish I was weaker."


Posted By: Silverback
Date Posted: 10/10/11 at 1:54am
I never understand why people that have not thrown far want to argue with what works for people that do throw far?  Don't lift and stay weak and show us how that works for you and get back to me.  My mind is open and thank goodness so is the gym today.   

-------------
Mule

Sportkilt
AST Sport Supplements


Posted By: D. Haakenson
Date Posted: 10/10/11 at 4:17am
Every advance in training theory (including the concept of weight training) throughout history has come because people refused to accept the status quo. Some of those people were us folks who don't throw far. Many of those people were probably seen as lazy weaklings who were looking for ways to achieve without working hard. 


Posted By: JSiau10
Date Posted: 10/10/11 at 6:23am

Originally posted by D. Haakenson D. Haakenson wrote:

The only thing I can say for certain is that all things being equal, you can't be too strong. 

I'm not sure that's always true. wasn't someone on here saying something about too much upper body strength negatively affecting the hammer throw?



-------------
I'm just an idiot, pretending to be smart.


Posted By: D. Haakenson
Date Posted: 10/10/11 at 6:29am
I think in some cases extreme upper body mass can limit range of motion in the hammer throw, which is why I used the caveat all other things being equal. 


Posted By: Alan H
Date Posted: 10/10/11 at 6:39am
Josh, quit debating the finer points.  You are nowhere near any point where you are "too strong to throw well".  Nowhere even vaguely, possibly near that point. Go lift like it's your religion for five to seven years, year-round and THEN we'll talk about being "too strong" in your upper body. Besides, it's not being "too strong" that's the issue. It's being too tight and inflexible.

 Go to the gym. Religiously. RELIGIOUSLY this winter, if you want to improve a lot next year. Three times a week sounds good. You're allowed to miss a day, once a month between now and March 1st.

If you want to get a little bit better, then go to the gym "kind of a lot" this winter. You know----like two times a week, and maybe you can miss a day every 3-4 weeks.

If you are happy throwing the way you are throwing right now, then don't go to the gym at all, or drop in once every two or three weeks. Your decision.   If that's the case, then knock off posting about it.

Do, or do not. Your choice.

I like you personally, Josh, but this is ridiculous.


-------------
Alan Hebert

Geezer-In-Training


Posted By: Silverback
Date Posted: 10/10/11 at 8:35am
Alan, you have come a long way baby.  I love it.  

-------------
Mule

Sportkilt
AST Sport Supplements


Posted By: Alan H
Date Posted: 10/10/11 at 8:51am
Well, Myles...I got better at first without getting stronger. But then I looked at the best guys in my class and I realized that they were a LOT stronger than I was. I took two full seasons to understand that if I wanted to be able to throw with the Big Lads, then I had to do two things...

-- get better technique
-- get stronger

If I just did one or the other, then I was only going to go so far.  I focused on technique the first couple of years.   My technique is now pretty good. There's always room for improvement, LOTS of room for improvement, but I know now that if I'm going to move to the next level, I just plain have to get stronger. I realized that before last years off-season. I understand it even more, now.

It's a priority decision...it's ALWAYS been a priority decision, but now one of my priorities is to throw bigger and to do that I gotta get stronger. If I do it smart...don't do stupid stuff, stretch and prepare before every workout, then I can get stronger and NOT blow up my knees and back.  Can Do. In fact, at this age MUST do. 

...but it's not THAT hard to do, if you use your head and listen to your body.

There's just no way around it. Right now, if I want to throw farther, I gotta get stronger and more explosive. TRUTH (probably) at this point I could flat bench for the rest of my life and at this age I would NEVER get so  tight that I'd hurt my hammers. It's just not gonna happen.

So what the hell?

Besides, I find that I LIKE going to the gym. 

The message to Josh remains the same. Find your priorities. It's YOUR life.  I'm not going to look down on Josh if he decides to stay at his level, now.  Maybe that's a wise path for him. I don't know, I'm not going to tell him what his decisions should be.

But dammit, if Josh wants to DO IT...to advance, to throw farther, then GET TO IT, dude.   Kwitcher moanin', and DO THE BUSINESS.  Myles, you told me, three years ago to find what works for me and DO IT.  My workout and my goals don't have to be the same as Greg Hadleys and Craig Smiths.  But set those goals, find what works, and DO IT.

Works for me.


-------------
Alan Hebert

Geezer-In-Training


Posted By: Alan H
Date Posted: 10/10/11 at 8:54am
All right, enough screaming. Done with this.

-------------
Alan Hebert

Geezer-In-Training


Posted By: Sean Betz
Date Posted: 10/10/11 at 9:01am
Originally posted by JSiau10 JSiau10 wrote:

Originally posted by D. Haakenson D. Haakenson wrote:

The only thing I can say for certain is that all things being equal, you can't be too strong. 

I'm not sure that's always true. wasn't someone on here saying something about too much upper body strength negatively affecting the hammer throw?

I have heard this too, but I think it is not accurate.  Dan McKim is probably the strongest upper body wise, and is consistently the best or 2nd best hammer thrower(Pockoski and him are fairly even).   There is some good stuff by Charles Poliquin, when he trained Jud Logan(American wire hammer champion).  Logan's throws went up when he increased his upper body strength, as well as improving his clean from 400 to 440, and using different types of squats and pulls every three weeks.  Before training with Poliquin, his upper back wasn't as strong as it needed to be to keep the hammer in a certain orbit, or at least this is my interpretation.  If strength can improve a lighter olympic event, it can most certainly improve the heavy events.  Chain yourself to a squat rack, Josh, and we'll see where you are in a year.



Posted By: mthompson33
Date Posted: 10/10/11 at 9:48am
Originally posted by D. Haakenson D. Haakenson wrote:

Originally posted by rknebel rknebel wrote:


My guess is that they would likely get their a$$ handed to them. 


Almost certainly. But to say that you can't throw without hurting yourself if you don't lift weights is ridiculous.




Ridiculous, really??? I would be willing to bet those guys that founded our sport lifted a whole hell of a lot more weight than any one here on the board does.  Not as much at once, but daily and repeatedly during the day.  And carried it for miles not feet... 

It's a matter of labor saving devices.  Now, the most time efficient way for a desk jockey to train his/her body to deal with the rigors of throwing is the exercise of "lifting weights" as we know it today...

To say you can't throw without hurting yourself if you don't lift weights IN A GYM, would be rediculous...  I know a few farm kids that could come out without stepping foot in a gym and throw safely with a little technique training...  But they are in the minority.


-------------
Matt Thompson

"If you wake up and you're not in pain, you know you're dead." -- Russian Proverb


Posted By: ROB EVANS
Date Posted: 10/10/11 at 3:00pm
Originally posted by mthompson33 mthompson33 wrote:

Originally posted by D. Haakenson D. Haakenson wrote:

Originally posted by rknebel rknebel wrote:


My guess is that they would likely get their a$$ handed to them. 


Almost certainly. But to say that you can't throw without hurting yourself if you don't lift weights is ridiculous.




Ridiculous, really??? I would be willing to bet those guys that founded our sport lifted a whole hell of a lot more weight than any one here on the board does.  Not as much at once, but daily and repeatedly during the day.  And carried it for miles not feet... 

It's a matter of labor saving devices.  Now, the most time efficient way for a desk jockey to train his/her body to deal with the rigors of throwing is the exercise of "lifting weights" as we know it today...

To say you can't throw without hurting yourself if you don't lift weights IN A GYM, would be rediculous...  I know a few farm kids that could come out without stepping foot in a gym and throw safely with a little technique training...  But they are in the minority.

+1 Agreed Matt.  We would refer to those guys from the days of old here in Oklahoma as COUNTRY STRONG.  Those guys worked to survive.  And I think I know one of those kids your talking about.  Culpepper is a freak of nature.


-------------
If Spencer Tyler is the gamma bomb of explosion, you and I are like single-serving flan cups in his lunchbox. Pasty, Jiggly, Delicious, but otherwise not very explosive. DUNCAN MCCALLUM


Posted By: Daniel McKim
Date Posted: 10/11/11 at 2:53pm
Josh, I hope you'll ignore some of the bashing you've
taken on this question.

People are wired differently - you don't have to train
like anyone else. Find what you enjoy to do, what works
for you and do it. If you'll notice my training log,
there are few guys who lift like me. Could I have a
better program? Probably. Could I learn from taking
more rest time? Sure. Do I overdue some lifts and under
value others? You bet. But you know what? It's what I
like and it's what I've found to work for me.

You'll be more consistent when you build something you
like and find that it works for you. Like Sean said, get
in a rack and stay a while. Experiment.

If a certain time of the day is optimal, lift then. If
you like doing certain lifts on certain days, then do
that! If you've got a buddy who pushes you and you have
a blast while you lift, then lift with him! If you like
to split up the body parts or movements, then do that! I
think you get my point.

You are your own test tube - what I do may not
necessarily work for you, and vice versa. It's an
awesome journey! Building your own workout, tweaking it
as you learn what works for you! It's a blast!

I applaud you for asking for advice and input.   

-------------
http://www.believethrower.com" rel="nofollow - http://www.believethrower.com



Posted By: billw
Date Posted: 10/13/11 at 12:33am
I can tell you what I did to make sure I get in the GYM...
 
I got a part time job at one

 so I know exactly when my workouts are going to be, and being at the gym gets me motivated even on days when there is very little motivation there...

-------------
Sponsored by friends of Billw


Posted By: Soul Eater
Date Posted: 10/19/11 at 9:43pm
Pre pay 12 visits to a real expensive Personal trainer who won't refund your
money. They will set a time and days for you to come in. That should do the
trick about getting to the Gym and consistency issue's.


Posted By: Sammy68123
Date Posted: 10/20/11 at 12:06am

Originally posted by Soul Eater Soul Eater wrote:

Pre pay 12 visits to a real expensive Personal trainer who won't refund your money. They will set a time and days for you to come in. That should do the trick about getting to the Gym and consistency issue's.

You would think that would work.  But I've had people (when I trained at club) who pre-paid for a boatload of sessions--hundreds of dollars--and then ended up blowing them off.  I always wanted to see people get the service they paid for, but it boggled my mind to see that they cared about it less than I did even after paying so much for it. 

Oh well . . . 



-------------
Teresa Merrick
Bellevue, NE


Posted By: Sean
Date Posted: 10/20/11 at 2:06am

An interesting observation from the responses here is the number of people that said, simply "Just go."

I don't know about anyone else, but I find my wagons circling a little tighter every year in terms of people I "relate" to. I mean I have lots of folks I talk to, but in terms of people I can spend endless time with its family or athletes. And that's about it.

And I've had lots of "other" people ask me how I stay motivated for the gym and I honestly don't have an answer for them other than "I just do." Like my life doesn't compute in the possibility of "don't enjoy the gym".

Back to my original point, I think anyone wired for it naturally or who programs that wiring into themselves is set but not everyone makes that leap. The responses in this thread just show how many people around here ARE those people.



Posted By: Soul Eater
Date Posted: 10/20/11 at 3:04am
If buying 12 visits with a PT doesn't work then nothing will and we are
wasting our time with this person. If he cared more about his throwing then
he would but it sounds like he wants to be a spoofhound.


Posted By: Daniel McKim
Date Posted: 10/20/11 at 8:01am
Originally posted by Soul Eater Soul Eater wrote:

spoofhound.


Hey, I'm one of those!   

-------------
http://www.believethrower.com" rel="nofollow - http://www.believethrower.com



Posted By: Sean Betz
Date Posted: 10/20/11 at 9:28am
Originally posted by Sean Sean wrote:

An interesting observation from the responses here is the number of people that said, simply "Just go."

I don't know about anyone else, but I find my wagons circling a little tighter every year in terms of people I "relate" to. I mean I have lots of folks I talk to, but in terms of people I can spend endless time with its family or athletes. And that's about it.

And I've had lots of "other" people ask me how I stay motivated for the gym and I honestly don't have an answer for them other than "I just do." Like my life doesn't compute in the possibility of "don't enjoy the gym".

Back to my original point, I think anyone wired for it naturally or who programs that wiring into themselves is set but not everyone makes that leap. The responses in this thread just show how many people around here ARE those people.

Very good point, Sean.   We all need direction and something to follow sometimes.  What brings someone back to the gym is results.  The best way to get results is to follow an outlined program by an expert.  I still write out my own program for at least 3 weeks.  It's hard to "just go" to the gym and get stronger.  Most of us have are programs already worked out in our head and the numbers we want to hit.



Posted By: Alan H
Date Posted: 10/20/11 at 10:33am
There is so much lifting and gym information and advice available here, that it's just incredible.  There is a HUGE array of approaches.  Andrew Gillie,  The Gnome goes out and hauls his kids around in the snow in New England, and picks up rocks and moves them around his yard. Low tech. It works for him.

Honestly I think that to some degree HOW we get it done, is irrelevant. Yeah, we can discuss which method gives the best results, but the #1 factor is just picking what you like and DOING IT.

Motivation to get in the gym?  I had none, until I started throwing. Oh, and until I read a little book called "Younger Next Year" for old farts like me, I knew I *should*... but somehow it didn't click.  Now it clicks.

You have to have a reason. For some guys, the reason is so embedded in their psyche that they don't even realize that they have it any more.  For me, throwing better became the reason. Shortly after throwing became the reason, and after seeing my father in law become so weak that he couldn't sit up, I realized that I needed to work out for the REST OF MY LIFE in order to be able to do the things I love to do, until the day comes that I have that stroke or bigass heart attack, or the chemotherapy takes me down.

Josh has to find his reason.  The reason has to be important to him, in order to motivate himself to do it.  If he doesn't have a reason that motivates him, it doesn't mean that he's a scumbag excuse for a human being. Hell, 90% of North American Humanity doesn't go to the gym, and who is going to say that 90% of North America is made up of scumbags?.  But IMHO if he doesn't have that reason to go, then there's no point in writing about a workout log, or asking for advice.

Find your reason.

Then go.

The next step is to be smart when you go....and for that, look at Sean Betz's last post.  THEN look for information here at NASGA and talk to some trainers.






-------------
Alan Hebert

Geezer-In-Training


Posted By: Soul Eater
Date Posted: 10/21/11 at 5:18am
You know that if you talk to ten different PT that are familiar with the HG
events your going to get 10 different ideas of how to set a program up.
However they will all have crossover. But I think the biggest things you can
do to have any success at all in the gym is to #1 get there, #2 have your
program written down, this will eliminate any guessing of what needs to be
done. #3 If your having time issue's stick with the basic's, multi joint
exercise's that best work for the events, #4 no more than 4-5 exercises and
#5 no more than 45min. that time will push you to get in and out. #6 2X a
week minimum, such as Mon & Thurs or Wed & Sat. I agree with Sean Betz
about results wether you have an expert writing your program or not, but
with an expert you are kind of insured success.


Posted By: eclarkhb
Date Posted: 10/28/11 at 2:59pm
I always had trouble staying motivated until I did a
couple of things:

1) Got equipment at home in my garage. Now it's always
there, there no commute & I can get in & out in whatever
time frame fits my schedule.

2) I started focusing on getting stronger & setting PRs.
Trying to do 5 sets of 10 bicep curls is boring as hell.
Setting a PR on a Big Lift (either with more weights or
more reps for a specific weight) is exciting. I did a 5x5
variation for about 6-9 months & then switched to 5/3/1 &
haven't looked back.


Posted By: Soul Eater
Date Posted: 10/28/11 at 5:50pm
I think that home gyms are great if you're highly motivated, live far from a
good gym, and you can afford high quality equipment and you have the
space to do it properly. These are important factors. The motivation thing in
this equation is very important because if you aren't using it you will
definitely hear about that soon enough. Some of the strongest guys I know
work out in their garages and so do some of the most inconsistent.


Posted By: Nathan Parker
Date Posted: 10/29/11 at 11:12am

My motivation comes from setting goals for next year in what marks I want to throw.  This was my first year throwing, and I am hooked now.  Before competing I was a pathetic potato chip eating coach troll for about 8 years.  Throwing has woke up the sleeping monster inside me.  My wife is now giving me the, "you're going to the gym again" look.

Yes i am dear, yes i am...



-------------
Sport Kilt
JDJ Caber Company
Hylete.com


Posted By: C. Smith
Date Posted: 10/29/11 at 9:47pm
If you want to be a better thrower/athlete, then you will do the things required to make you one. 

Period. 


-------------


Posted By: bigirish01
Date Posted: 10/31/11 at 4:41am

Originally posted by C. Smith C. Smith wrote:

If you want to be a better thrower/athlete, then you will do the things required to make you one. 

Period. 

thats really the bottom line



-------------
Jay "Big Daddy" O'Neill



Print Page | Close Window

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 10.11 - http://www.webwizforums.com
Copyright ©2001-2012 Web Wiz Ltd. - http://www.webwiz.co.uk